Gad's Sprites

[Gad]

Hooold on.

DONT CRITICIZE THE DUDES SPRITING IF YOU CANT DO ANY BETTER!!

That's the point of critique. Film-Critic doesn't make films, but he criticize them.

[prince_freeza]

That's the point of critique. Film-Critic doesn't make films, but he criticize them.

that case doent really relate to this one at all, not even closely. i mean he can criticize like normal people, and not starting to act like ur sprite sucks and he can do waaay better job.

[Ascor]

You disappointed me =(

C'mon gad don't let me hang down

come on dude thats really irritating cut the guy some slack . you see that what i really hate!
DONT CRITICIZE THE DUDES SPRITING IF YOU CANT DO ANY BETTER!!

i would like to see you make better pants that he did. which you totally wouldn't.
@Gad nice work i just know you can do better... its just that you probably didnt sprite for a while so you need some warmup to get this right thats all. thumbs up mate!

srry for acting like that but i had to say...

Argh ^{i don't care if you give me another warning simon} GFY!

I was just trying to point out that he has done way better sprites before and this sprite was not his usual quality!

So you say everyone who isn't better shouldn't critize?
How should that person then get better to be able to critize if noone (except people with natural talent [like gad]) is good enough to critize someone else?

and by the way

You disappointed me =( Cause i know you can do it better

C'mon gad don't let me hang down return to your normal quality

i just know you can do better...

I know it's difficult but try to read between the lines.

[Lauli]

can all this "fail" discussion be done here so we can get back on topic?

can all this "DONT CRITICIZE THE DUDES SPRITING IF YOU CANT DO ANY BETTER!!" discussion be done here so we can get back on topic?
So yea, prince. Hahaha.

Nice sprites, Gad.

[Gad]

Well, I guess that's kinda "miner".

[prince_freeza]

niiiice one gad. rly smooth sprites dude. and i love that hair

[SparK]

the last one is kinda... plastic, I think the shading is too bright, try to use darker tones for the top layers of the shading "the shading contrast is too elevated for the eye apreciation" (i think that's how a medieval professional spriter would put it)
and his shoulders are too high close to the head, it looks like he has negative neck... try to put head a little higher or lower the shoulders and it will be fixed

(sorry about that, i'm not a spriter (bad hand for drawing) but i have good eyes)

[Gad]

Well, thanks. I wanted this jacket to look kinda plastic and shiny. Gonna repair this somehow today .

[snorsorbet]

The hair looks too back heavy, and his shoulders are a bit too close to each other. I think the shiny jacket is okay, it might be leather ;P

@Critique 'discussion': None of you guys seem to be able to recognize criticism. What we want to achieve is something constructive, right?
Good criticism involves pointing out the flaws in the object or behaviour being criticised. The way to 'fix' the fault should be very clear, for an instance, saying "The eyes look like sh*t." isn't a very good way of criticising. Saying "Your picture looks like sh*t." is even worse. A good way of putting it would be "I don't like the eyes very much, they are way too dark compared to the rest of the picture."
So yeah, think twice before calling something you have written saying something negative about something critique.

[Gad]

http://i44.tinypic.com/x3iv7l.png

TEH EDIT!