Mafia

[Alblaka]

well if it is a fake sheriff, then I'll obviously revale him and we'll lynch him next round, though I won't do that yet, 'cuz of the town drunk

Uhm, but why would we lynch him? Just cuz he tries to take certain people out, this doesnt mean he is mafia, is he?
Let's check this:

1. He is a mafia trying to confuse us into killing each other.
   
2. He is a Pseudo Sheriff trying to help us, but didn't realize he is PSEUDO yet.
   
3. He isn't a Sheriff but one of the other classes who can reveal players (Investigator?)
   
4. He is a citizen, trying to kill people at random (for whatever reason).
   
5. He is amor and now tries to kill the love couple to eventually get a Mafia down...
   
6. Dunno...
   

Though, agreed, choice #1 seems most reasonable.
However, it's also possible to be #2 or #3. In this cases killing him would give us a big disadvantage :/
#4/#5 wouldn't be that bad to kill, since the person isn't helping us at all with these things.

So, in math it would be 5:4 arguments (counting #1 tripled and #2/#3 doubled each) FOR killing him.


However, this entire thingy does only apply IF he is a fake Sheriff... we'll see it after we lynched the Koala
(I hope we got one.... this would take Mafia down to 1 guy only)


PS: Je it's my first round of Mafia... and i'm trying not to screw it up and therefore will built all my conclusions on math and logic