Mafia

[Ramond]

sounds kind of good, a huge disadvantage would be: mafia knows exactly what we're doing in the night rounds, and if they kill a doctor, they have the chance to kill the sheriff with a "normal kill" + "mafia vig kill" combo, 'cuz one doctor only heals one bullethole...

though I'm not a fan of the role-pm'ing thing, it kind of ruins the fun, and wasn't it forbidden in some rounds before already?

a) Yes, it requires one doctor per kill to survive. Means if somebody is targeted twice in a night he needs both doctors to cover him to survive. If 3 people target the same victim, he dies regardless.

b) I tried to forbid it, but it never stopped the players :P

c) Sheriff only finds out the side of the target, not the role; it has never been different and never will (too great advantage).

As for votes: Throw more in!