[C] Walker - 2.08

[YinYin]

Phantom Guard Phantom Punch launces lower

It still looks ridiculous because it goes up so perfectly straight without any x motion.

However, I realised that is changes team to opponent so while it certainly rebounds balls back to opponent they just miss and the wall itself hurt Walker.

You could again use the little drop held object trick - same as the wall bounce - to rebound without changing teams. (held object becoming the rebounded one - but not changing teams because it was created before the parent object got hit)

removing Phantom Punch follow-up from Phantom Guard. Maybe instead add a stronger throw attack.

Certainly do that - even though I would miss the non jump PP.

As I use the Super Punch motion for the counterattack, should he get a new Super Punch?

The non jump PP perhaps?

Deeps normal A and Strike hits so low that Phantom Dash cannot go through them. Strike also has magical 3F start-up with amazing range making hop SK a very dangerous aproach as well. Is this how it should be, or should I do something about it (add projectile move or long-range counterattack or attack-while-moving-forward-attack...)?

Maybe you should consider making the PD shorter again - but go all the way with its evasive properties: just like Rudolfs dodge, no body.

Also should you ever consider making him run again I would really love to see this as his run attack:

Similar to Woodys, except you would need to continue a combo after the second hit as the last one knocks down.

edit: gotta add - I agree with everything else.