01-31-2016, 05:59 AM
(01-31-2016, 03:32 AM)TheNave Wrote: Apoc: he's a smart veteran player, It's highly likely that he's mafia, saw A-man's post asking for help from the doc and came up with the trapper excuse to prevent the doc from actually trapping A-Man... In my opinion none of the role names fit the Trapper-ability, and this "common" role was actually only used once or twice in Ramond's games and pretty overpowered aswell, even more so if it's mafia-aligned... so yeah, I think the only reason for bringing up that role was to prevent the doctor from saving that person (good thing he didn't listen)
I knew someone would suspect me because of that.
In my opinion, there's a "Trapper" playing. It's not a sure thing, but there are 17 players in this round. That's 34 special abilities (Ramond said that each role has two abilities, one active and one passive). I for one cannot come up with 17 active abilities so easily. That's why I think he included a "Trapper". He probably has a certain amount of traps, though.
My point is that, this time, we don't know the abilities nor the alignments of each role, so we have to be extra careful.
The Doctor saving the first player who asks for protection doesn't seem like a very wise thing to do, in my opinion.
Even more so, I find it hard to believe that the Doctor saved A-MAN. If I were the Doctor, I wouldn't have saved him, just in case. I would have saved myself.
That leads me to these personal conclusions:
* A-MAN is the Doctor.
* A-MAN was not Mafia's target => he's lying, or he's not lying and somehow got wrong information.
* A-MAN was Mafia's target => the Doctor is brave, or has a passive ability to automatically save himself (a number of times?), so he took the risk.

Chat

