Suggestion's??

[Happy Clown]

Both look pretty good. The shading you are going to go with depends on purpose behind sprites. If you think about making whole character, go with simple style, it will make your life easier and i still look good enough

Yup you are right, i want my sprites to look smooth so 20℅ done  I'm creating both style at a same time.
But I'll see which one looks better in game tanks for your concern.