Mafia (Round 13, retry...)

[Evil Sonidow]

I'll pass this time. If only everyone posted,we might have more clues. Lynching people that isn't even here is not fun.

The problem is that he doesn't play but he's still a question mark in the persons list. I see no problem.

zomg?
ok ill quit the 'jerk' strategy (even though that was a part of my strategy) if you guys not vote for me
i am innocent, sorry for being unhelpful
btw, who do we think is going to die next by mafia hands??

Death by mafia hands is unavoidable now that the doctor is dead, so the focus is finding who is mafia. You can start out by showing us your theories gathered with your strategy (if you did have one).

BP post, spoilered due to size (Click to View)

Code:

Code:
[15:33] <@BluePhoenix> silva
[15:33] <@BluePhoenix> you're not playing mafia, right?
[15:34] <Silvaer> no
[15:34] <@BluePhoenix> no as in "no, I'm not playing?"
[15:34] <Silvaer> no, i'm not playing.

Ergo: don't accuse Silva. Bot = useless placeholder. Useless placeholders = unimportant. Unimportant = not any role. Not any role = not involved in mafia-game. Not involved in mafia-game = to be ignored. /silva-accusation.

With that being said, let's try to get some order in here. Going by Blue Phoenix-logic, we should pick out the ones that did NOT accuse SirFrog. Why? There are/were 15 players at the beginning, only 3 of them belong to mafia. The chance to hit a mafia-member in the first round is 1:5 or 20%. We had no information about the strategy everyone had, so this was just a happy guessing round. The only information that there was around was among the mafia-members: they know each other and lynching one of their team-mates is a pretty bad choice. 2vs12 makes it really hard to win for mafia. One bad move and they're pretty much unveiled. Ergo: potential mafiosi would not accuse one of their mates. So, who did not accuse SirFrog at all?
- Nave
- SirFrog (lol)
- Alectric
- Drahcir
This would lead me to the conclusion that we should keep an eye on the three guys. Right, at least one of them is lying but we can't tell who. There's still a lot unclear and I hope this will clear up with the next lynch.

Following my 6th sense, I'd spontaneously accuse Drahcir. Defend yourself or die lol

BP has a valid point. Thus, I change my accusation of Silva to Drahcir, but I maintain mine on Alectric. You need to show us the true purpose of your strategy for me to take this off.