Challenge Me!!!Monolith sprites versus yours sprites

[Monolith]

here my entry
Monolith VS Gad
voting starts,sorry for long wait,i was not at home these days i just was online whit a phone.
always read rules,cuz there can be some changes ,happy voting

[Ariel]

vote for gad

[Monolith]

wow good job Gad,i will try to do worse,realy

vote for gad

Rule 5
Voting: first five members votes will be deathline.When voting you have to write why voted (dont write i liked that sprites.Write which detail you liked,is body proportions good or shading good)

[Ariel]

okay than
better shading,proportions and the colors looks better..
btw
u have too much rules...
i dont think that need to explain and wirte y bla bla bla
cuz in any contest and those thigse u just need to vote on the pull without too much words anyways the last ones u battle if i remember right u said just thank to the one u vote
so i cant get it u r doing it to much hard...

[Monolith]

okay than
better shading,proportions and the colors looks better..
btw
u have too much rules...
i dont think that need to explain and wirte y bla bla bla
cuz in any contest and those thigse u just need to vote on the pull without too much words anyways the last ones u battle if i remember right u said just thank to the one u vote
so i cant get it u r doing it to much hard...

well u see just first 5 votes here can be accepted,not like in a contest.this is not a contest

[Wiro]

Voting for monolith. No reason.

[~Dome~]

Wow .. really? If someone votes for your opponent you tell him to reason his vote. but when someone votes for you without naming reasons, you just thank him and say nothing?

Thats lame.

Anyway, I'll go with Gad because I like the contrast and the pose more. Both are great sprites though.

[alphafighters]

I vote for Gad. The contrast in the shadings are perfectly balanced and is not too bright whereas monolith's one is a little dark and recessive. So my vote would go for Gad.

[Monolith]

Wow .. really? If someone votes for your opponent you tell him to reason his vote. but when someone votes for you without naming reasons, you just thank him and say nothing?

Thats lame.

Anyway, I'll go with Gad because I like the contrast and the pose more. Both are great sprites though.

you also need to write reason if you vote for me
don't blame me if you think thats lame

[Madara Uchiha]

Then why did you like Wiro post when he voted for you? You've just contradicted; Like I've mentioned in my signature, contradicting yourself is the source of stupidity.
Anyway I vote for Gad, I noticed that your version of the sprite shading isn't as good as Gad. The sword held on left hand doesn't have the spike sticking out at the end.
I have to say though, I really think your improving.