RaMafia (round 1 - end)

[MangaD]

If he is doc/cop, it would be stupid to say so.

It would be stupid to don't say so if he's gonna die... it's his only chance of surviving. There aren't any 'nice' outcomes from this if he's a special.

It just looks to me like you are both forcing the cop/doc to reveal themselves... which really sounds suspicious right now.

I clearly stated otherwise in a post in this previous page =_=

If AmadisLFE were Mafia and wanted to save his skin, he would probably have pretended to be cop by now, because as you said, it's his only chance of surviving. Just saying. But doesn't matter. As you said, his death will provide us with a lot of information. Things just got simple. Either Hellbalzer is cop, or he and TheNave are Mafia. Either way, things got easier for the good guys. Because we either lynch a bad guy on the first day, or lynch 2 bad guys on the next 2 days.

[Ramond]

In fact I have been wondering why we aren't killing off inactives. Since they, you know, don't contribute at all, especially in Day Phases, and when Doomsday dawns with just 2 Mafia vs 3 Citizens (which is in fact a likely occurrence)... we'll have one inactive citizen and good job town, you shamed yourself

Therefore, I highly suggest not to kill Amadis for now.

[Apocalipsis]

I'll Unvote AmadisLFE until Hellblazer comes back and explains why he voted against him... if it's that stupid reason...

@Ramond
I agree with you about that... Jernemies and PF didn't post even once. And they were online I think.

[empirefantasy]

Voting for Apoc

how did that came out?!

[MangaD]

In fact I have been wondering why we aren't killing off inactives. Since they, you know, don't contribute at all, especially in Day Phases, and when Doomsday dawns with just 2 Mafia vs 3 Citizens (which is in fact a likely occurrence)... we'll have one inactive citizen and good job town, you shamed yourself

Therefore, I highly suggest not to kill Amadis for now.

In fact, there is a chance the Mafia are none of the guys who are debating, and they could be just laughing at all this. If neither AmadisLFE nor Hellbalzer are Mafias, this will be a win round for the Mafia.

I tried to explain this, we could just wait for the cop to check on AmadisLFE or reveal himself and there would be less chances of making a big mistake. But well, both TheNave and Apocalipsis seem to be in a hurry with the kill, and they are in my original list of suspects of who would kill a first-timer, so I want to help them!
I am kinda eager to know if AmadisLFE is really a mafia or not. Because if he is not... And even if he is, they will remain suspects to me.

Edit: Scratch Apocalipsis, he seems to have finally listened to reason...

[empirefantasy]

@MangaD

i highly doubt amadis and hellblazer are both townes, one of them is surely mafia. why in the hell would sb accuse another person pretending that he is the cop?! only if he is trying to pressure like ramond is doing

[Simoneon]

I think it's too early to make any conclusions so I'll vote no kill. But I might change my vote when Hellblazer replies about this matter.
Other than that, LutiChris is also acting weird, but that is kind of common I guess...

Also, a bit offtopic, but when I play this game in real life we usually set a themed environment before we play and introduce ourselves. It makes the game more interesting for me because the game gets a flavour of real role playing. So even simple citizens get some fun playing their "role". Any thoughts on why we don't do it?

[MangaD]

@empirefantasy

Problem is, Hellbalzer did not say he is cop. He just accused AmadisLFE "because of something he knows". That is why I don't want to rush anything. Doing stupid things is characteristic of him. Of course, not saying that is the case.

Why did he not just say he is cop? The doc would heal him and it would be less suspicious. Moreover, the chances of guessing a Mafia at the first night were 2/12... But if he says that he is cop, and if AmadisLFE is not Mafia, then he is surely Mafia. That is why I want to see Hellbalazer confess if he is cop or not, or if he's just pressuring or whatever.

[Apocalipsis]

Scratch Apocalipsis, he seems to have finally listened to reason...

I always listen to reason. It's the new information (AmadisLFE's post that I facepalmed) that made me change my opinion. I was unaware that Hellblazer can possibly have that special reason to vote against Amadis.

Voting for Apoc

I guess this was random, but I find it weird that 3 people voted me so far, with no solid reason.

[Jernemies]

Obligatory "I'm alive" post, since it's only fair. I don't have anything to say, majorly because there's a lot of discussion (it's happening even now).

I don't have an opinion. I've been trying to read the past pages, but I fail paying attention for long enough (tired much?). I can't figure out why everyone is voting for Amadis other than posting statistics/things he pulled from his a** and Hellbzaler "knowing something special", to which I say "grain of salt". There isn't a lot to go around in reliable statistics/roles out of anyway (unless you want to play the "Russian roulette" way), so I'm not going to try.

I'll try to catch up and say something, though if I have nothing, then nothing is what you'll get.
I do want to say that there's a lot of votes flinging back and forth, but I guess that can be attributed to pressuring.