RaMafia (round 1 - end)

[MangaD]

If you're sure that Hellblazer is not the Cop

I'm not sure of anything, just putting the cards on the table.

AmadisLFE's death would provide us with a lot of information, whatever the result.

So you are willing to sacrifice someone, just to know his identity, whatever the result. That's no different than my first position on the matter, and you proved me wrong. Now you change your mind because hellbalzer gave an hint that sounds fishy. He's the kind of guy that likes to draw attention towards himself, that's why I'm reluctant in lynching AmadisLFE immediately, without having solid proof. I wouldn't be surprised if Hellbalzer were just a townie, and we would lose 2 innocent guys just like that. I dare Hellblazer to say here "I am cop". If someone else is cop, then he will know for sure that Hellblazer is lying and therefore he is a Mafia goon, and will not even bother guessing on him the next night, giving him more chances to find the other goon.

Also, AmadisLFE faced 4 votes against him and did not state to be Doctor or Cop... so I guess it's safe to assume he's Townie or mafia.

I really doubt he has a special role, he would have revealed it by now if that was the case...

If he is doc/cop, it would be stupid to say so. If he is cop and reveals himself, the true doc would be confused on who to heal (Hellbalzer or AmadisLFE), and we could lose the cop. If he is doc and reveals himself, then even if he heals himself next nights, the cop wouldn't be able to reveal himself or the Mafia would know who they both are and just target one of them.

It just looks to me like you are both forcing the cop/doc to reveal themselves... which really sounds suspicious right now. What Hellbalzer is doing could be just a trick to lure the real cop out, and at the same time cover for his teammates. Still, I won't vote for any of you right now, because this is just a theory, and we will know who is who when AmadisLFE dies. If AmadisLFE ends up being a townie, Hellbalzer and TheNave will be next. I guess this settles it then.

Unvote No-Kill. Vote AmadisLFE.