06-14-2015, 12:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-14-2015, 01:01 PM by Apocalipsis.)
@LutiChris
@empirefantasy
I checked TheNave, result was "Citizen".
@MangaD
Like I said, I never played it with that rule on these forums. And that rule wasn't specified anywhere, so don't blame me...
But as I replied to a PM regarding the game, I broke that rule and I apologize.
My excuse is that I believed that the Host knew about it. Not like it compensates anything.
@Jernemies
I'll probably skip the next game, but I'm against those rules too.
The 'no discussion during night' seems useless to me in the 'strategy' sense, but cuts the flow of the discussions in the thread.
The 'dead men tell no tales' simply reduces the activity drastically, and we always struggle to get a decent amount of players to play. Plus Mafia will probably start killing the most active players first, resulting in a boring game in the late rounds.
Now that I know all the roles, this list was pretty spot on: 4/4 specials (didn't expect AmadisLFE and MangaD to be Goons, though). I included Hellblazer for obvious reasons, and TheNave because I checked him in first night.
@empirefantasy
I checked TheNave, result was "Citizen".
@MangaD
Like I said, I never played it with that rule on these forums. And that rule wasn't specified anywhere, so don't blame me...
(05-23-2015, 01:47 PM)Ariel Wrote: I understand your confusing, ill make it fair so for now this rule [Can't speak at night] wont be active
It will be added next round
But as I replied to a PM regarding the game, I broke that rule and I apologize.
My excuse is that I believed that the Host knew about it. Not like it compensates anything.
@Jernemies
I'll probably skip the next game, but I'm against those rules too.
The 'no discussion during night' seems useless to me in the 'strategy' sense, but cuts the flow of the discussions in the thread.
The 'dead men tell no tales' simply reduces the activity drastically, and we always struggle to get a decent amount of players to play. Plus Mafia will probably start killing the most active players first, resulting in a boring game in the late rounds.
(05-22-2015, 11:39 PM)Apocalipsis Wrote: As I think that I'm gonna die tonight, I'll post significant thoughts on some players, just in case:
- Hellblazer: It seems he's not the cop from the last post... >_>
- Prince_freeza: No posts yet. That's troublesome, even if he's innocent.
- AmadisLFE: He's really participative and gives out so much information, which is a rare thing if he's mafia, but a good idea if he's the Godfather.
- TheNave: He's participative and I usually agree with him a lot, so I wouldn't want to kill him in these early lynchs.
- MangaD: He's really suspicious imo, because he bandwagoned me for no reason as the day started, and he's incredibly eager for AmadisLFE to be checked. I know that I was the one to suggest the checking of suspicious players to prove their (temporary) innocence, or not, but I think it would be wiser to check him. The reason is simple: if he's mafia and wants AmadisLFE to be checked, there's a great chance that AmadisLFE's the Godfather, and he's a goon. There's also the chance of him being Godfather (he's really participative), and he just want innocent people to be checked. Just thinking out loud here.
- Ramond: He voted against me for no reason (probably wanted to point out bandwagoners since it was the third post of the day), but that's not that suspicious. Another (subtle) suspicious thing is that he wanted to end the day prematurely, presumably to kill AmadisLFE and avoid the No-kill. However, I also wanted to end this day by that time, so there's that.
So, those are the thoughts that I have right now. If I were Cop I would check MangaD, Prince Freeza and Ramond, in that order.
Now that I know all the roles, this list was pretty spot on: 4/4 specials (didn't expect AmadisLFE and MangaD to be Goons, though). I included Hellblazer for obvious reasons, and TheNave because I checked him in first night.

Chat

