RaMafia (round 1 - end)

[MangaD]

*MangaD: Faking a PM out of the blue is not something I expected from him. He said that he wanted to discredit A-MAN's screenshot, but why didn't he say so in the same post?

Yeah I understand. Though you might notice that I made Rhino's PM look like a troll and not really a threat PM. Even Rhino found this funny and clearly discredited my PM, he did not even accuse me (he only accused Luti and A-Man) even though he knew the PM was fake.

Initially I didn't know whether A-Man's screenshot was a fake or not, but after Rhino's reply I got less suspicious of him and came up with the 3rd option - him being set up. I did not reveal the PM was fake right away because I wanted to see A-Man's reaction, though I did a mistake in the screenshot and his reaction was not what I expected.

Though his reaction kinda backfired on him, because he tried to find flaws, as if he knew the PM had to be a fake.

If you still are not convinced, that's ok, I would suspect me too if I were in your position (assuming you are not Mafia).

As I've mentioned we, even though we could afford to lose a townie just to know if he is one its best not to. Even though he caused quite a stir and we were there to take the bait i don't see why we should lynch anyone this first round. a little over 50% chance that he's innocent. Since everyone is so inclined to lynch their way I would draw attention to those that follow the herd.

Why would he bait himself in the first place? Why is he so sure that you are Mafia when everyone else is confused? Divine inspiration? Amen.

He even appealed everyone to lynch someone the 1st round, unlike you are doing. Normally, I would go with no-kill, but he's way too suspicious right now.

You say you'd draw attention to those that follow the herd, say that after we know his true identity. Right now, the way I see it, you could very well be his teammate and are trying to protect him. He could just be accusing you in order to lift suspicions from you, should he go down this day.