RaMafia (round 1 - end)

[A-Man]

The rest of the arguments against Rhino were just to see how he'd respond. I must say I'm not very happy with him revealing sensitive information like that. Maybe I would have trusted him more if he hadn't reveal anything. Well, he did not reveal everything and for that I am glad.

I'd not be happy either if the info he gave away were true.

2. No kill is bad strategy!

No, it is not. What if you lynch the sheriff/doctor?

I'd care for the former, if it wasn't the 3rd night already. Now, if the sheriff is targeted for lynching, there would be enough people he checked on to divert the accusation simply by accusing other people. As for the doctor, chances we hit him are 3 times less compared to the chances we hit a mafia.

What if you lynch a citizen? It will all benefit the Mafia. Sure you are not forgetting that we still have a sheriff that is doing his job?

What if that, what if this. If we hit a citizen, it's not a big deal. It's a game where you're supposed to take risks. The sheriff is doing his job, right, but even that is only supposed to increase the likelihood of hitting a mafia (to 100% if lucky). But we really can't just wait for the sheriff to find a mafia for certain. This game can't last more than 7 rounds, (usually even less; it goes as far as 7 rounds only ~6% of the times according to the sim). We're at round 3 already!..

I hope we see a tie breaker which doesn't go towards the no-kill choice.