RaMafia 2

[MangaD]

Unlikely.

Where are your supporting details?

Unlikely does not mean for granted. But I think only 1 inquisitor on the town side fighting 1 hellblazer inquisitor would be unfair for both parties. Because as you said, the town inquisitor cannot be trusted (bad for town), so killing both inquisitors means one ww down (bad for hellblazers). In this scenario, the inquisitor would be a powerless role. But then again, we do not know the ratio of players, so everything is possible.

Not really, as long as the inquisitors survive long enough. About TheNave, we don't even know if he is town aligned or not. If he is not, then the town inquisitors are safe for now. Moreover, this could be a plotting between TheNave and Bamboori. I do not think Bamboori was this naive as to expose TheNave without thinking. He either wants to kill TheNave or to plot with him.

But if he's a werewolf, how does he even be in danger if you guys don't want to lynch an inquisitor? But if he is, assuming the werewolves think about the inquisitors in such a manner that you do, then he dies and your grand plot falls apart. TheNave and Bamboori are associates you say? So you'll kill Bamboori, but not TheNave.

The point is, Bamboori's information, regardless of his alignment, are truthy; if he lies, then he takes the risk of being figured out as the information he comes up with is verifiable. That's why I assume it's safer to trust his word than the word of an inquisitor. So if you're going against Bamboori, why not go with TheNave?

If TheNave is ww then he is in danger IF some other inquisitor(s) show up later in the game saying something different than him. But he won't be killed so soon if the knights protect him.

I say there is a possibility of TheNave and Bamboori being both ww, no? There are endless possibilities. I just choose to vote Bamboori because I don't think a townie would expose the inquisitor without first consulting the town.

It is the same as lynching the inquisitors. We are 11 players. Killing inquisitors could be killing 2 townies and one hellblazer. Or killing 1 townie and 0 hellblazers. And killing the knights could be something of the sort. Also, nothing guarantees the scout will find all inquisitors/knights early. You could have the bad luck of killing the townie ones and the hellblazers being undetected for long.

Same? No, of course there is a difference. You guys proposed the 2 vs 1 composition because you figured 2 may be the number required for inquisitors to function. With Knights, one can be useful by himself. I'm really annoyed to see that you're already doing your calculation based on the assumption you favored. That serves to show how biased your arguments have become.

Same can be said about you. Nothing guarantees that the ww's have a knight to begin with. And you suggest we kill the first knight we encounter immediately. Wouldn't it be fun to reach the end of the game and find out there was only 1 knight, and who happened to be on town side? Or wouldn't it be fun to kill the town knight and the scout only find the ww knight when there is little hope for victory?