Mafia

[Alectric]

woops. Sorry for getting killed guys ;P

I never actually got to use my shot. I didnt know who would be a good idea to shoot, so i was going to keep till next round... BUT IT NEVER CAME

[Apocalipsis]

OK not to make this a threat or anything, but we've basically confirmed Apoc as Trapper.
How about we both send the Doctor PM that Ramond sent us to Apoc?

i will send it as well, since im the only 100% doctor. (was)

That's genius. Your PM is identical to Bamboori's. And he has been confirmed as doctor... then both Nave and Empirefantasy are lying. As Nave was checked as citizien before:

Accusing Nave, the godfather.

Btw, damn good luck on the first checking, Divisor xD

After killing Nave, in night round:
*Blow Fly saves me (or don't, if you don't want, but it sounds plausible considering the number of traps I have left).
*Divisor checks Jerkington (or Empirefantasy maybe). Result has to be mafia.
*Marshall does Marshall's things.
*I trap someone's room and pray to get a mafia. The chances of getting one mafia is not really bad:

Complete list feat. roles (Click to View)

Jerkington - Mafia
Empirefantasy - Mafia
Drahcir - Citizien
Blow_Fly - Doctor
Magnamancy - Insomniac
Alectric - Vigilante
Apocalipsis - Trapper
Bamboori - Doctor
Divisor - Sheriff
Nave - Godfather
Marshall - Marshall

Of the not-mafia persons alive, I can save:
*Me. That would be stupid, if Blow Fly saves me.
*Marshall.
*Divisor.
*Blow Fly.

That means I have 33% chances of killing one mafia.

Edit: After reading Ramond's PM again, it seems I can't kill the sheriff with my traps, because he doesn't leave his room. That's good, but it's kind of useless now :p

Edit2:
I'm thinking about any possible gaps right now, and what Jerkington can say to defend himself. As we know that Nave and Empirefantasy lied, they're both definetly mafia. Up to every role still alive, he can choose to claim he is either:
*Marshall. He's Jerkington, he's not Marshall.
*Trapper. In that case I will ask him to post his Ramond's pm, then I post mine, Bamboori's and Blow Fly's and you will detect he's lying.
*Sheriff. In that case, I ask Divisor and Jerkington to send me their PMs, I post them along Bamboori's and Blow Fly's and we'll get to know who lies.

If Divisor send me his PM and it's in the same format and style than the other three I have, we can end this right now, though.

[Marshall]

well done, ghost Bamboori!

Let's try and decide who Divisor should check. Jerkington or Empirefantasy.
From the brief observations I have made [and just one look at every single post without much thinking just so that only the obvious parts stick out rather than thinking too deeply into it (yes, that's a strategy ._.)]
1) Jerkington's silence makes me very suspicious
2) The Nave always defends empirefantasy

so yeah... those two should be the mafia all right

EDIT: just read apoc's post above, seems like he had it all summed up = =

[Ramond]

Just FYI, from next round on I'm going to include the PM templates in my first post to try to prevent the "send role PM to prove the role" thing. It doesn't completely prevent the PM traffic between players, but if multiple people claim the same thing, they have the same credibility...

[Apocalipsis]

Mafia had some advantage in this round though. We started 3:8, chances of doctor healing or me getting a mafia is not that bad (30%), but there were also possibilities of me killing one of the doctors (20%). That if I decided to trap and they don't save the same person. To me, it was very obvious that they would kill someone in first day round, 3:7.
We failed in our FIRST attempt to get a mafia, that happens in 90% of the rounds. After that ratio is 3:6, then they use two kills on the same night, and even though doctors and my chances of killing a saving a citizien/killing a mafia was was something like 33%, I had 22% chances of killing a doctor. Now, in third round, ratio is 3:4, we fail and we lose. And even if you say we had lots of specials, Mafia has three members and they even had one vigilante. And... this time Insomniac was kinda of useless with all the specials around.

I'm not using this to justify this kind of 'cheap' methods... Wait, I am. We don't want to lose, we will do everything we can to gain advantage.

[Ramond]

Well I didn't directly aim it at the citizens, just for fairer gameplay in future

Also showed me that letting everybody have a unique role also kind of squeezes the "pretending to be role x" thing, so in future, there'll always be enough citizens around

[TheNave]

OK not to make this a threat or anything, but we've basically confirmed Apoc as Trapper.
How about we both send the Doctor PM that Ramond sent us to Apoc?

i will send it as well, since im the only 100% doctor. (was)

That's genius. Your PM is identical to Bamboori's. And he has been confirmed as doctor...

what the hell?! What is this?! That's f***ing impossible, his pm is faked or something, I got the real one!

gimme a decent picture uploader except for tinypic or photobucket because those resize the picture, or imageshack which doesn't even try to upload it atall, and I'll give you the screenshot on full HD or whatsoever so you'll belive me

damn morrons, I was only trying to help, the whole game, it's our LAST damn chance right now, and you're wasting it because of a faked pm?! that's madness... but yeah, if it makes you happy, go on... I'm the doctor, but who needs him? just kill me, pewh... it's not like we loose when you kill me

EDIT:
accusing blow_fly, blow_fly, blow_fly !!!!1

EDIT2:
thanks marshall:
http://i.imgur.com/37sxo.png
^full quality pic

Marshall edited this post 05-14-2011 06:17 PM because:

imgur is a good pic host

[Bamboori]

i gotta say that naves pm is identical to mine.
so either apoc or nave is mafia (if the pic is fake).

[Divisor]

That's interesting...

If Nave is telling the truth, then Apoc and blow_fly are both Mafia.
But, Nave could also use an old PM from an old Mafia game (where he was the doctor)/acquired Bamboori's PM in this round and simply copypaste the text into a blank PM. It's not impossible to do.

[TheNave]

That's interesting...

If Nave is telling the truth, then Apoc and blow_fly are both Mafia.
But, Nave could also use an old PM from an old Mafia game (where he was the doctor)/acquired Bamboori's PM in this round and simply copypaste the text into a blank PM. It's not impossible to do.

1st. check the dates
2nd. I'm not sure but I can't remember beeing the doctor in a previous mafia game and I didn't "acquired Bamboori's PM", you can ask him, he never sent me anything atall

and yes, I tell ya, apoc and blow_fly are f***ing things up right now and I'm damn mad