Char Selection

[Hero destroyer]

Dear, LFE.
Actually, I don't know if it's really worth it.
I just noticed characters are in a lot of groups.
Example:
-Bonu, Batman, Anti-Davis...are balanced fighters.
-LouisAS, Vegeta, BurningIce(My project, not very good feedback, though)...are over-powered fighters.
-Alexander(Template), SorcererB1...are weak fighters.
So, I'm just thinking at the char selection(both mainsite and forum), there's a selection like these three. Every time I saw someone post a little bit over-powered char, then after a day, there will be at least 6 comments or more. As for weak char, I'm still not sure, but I think it will less likely similar. I'm doing this for less war in this forum and make it more organized. Some people like me usually like over-powered chars, but others like one of my friends like weak chars(He use it to replace bandit and beat the a** out of him)
What do you guys think?

[Monolith]

about forum no need,but about mainsite good idea,but there will be lots work to bp or mh-razen to do it.
but some peoples,like admins have o decide if its week char or strong

[Bamboori]

i would rather suggest some kinda stats list for every char, like this:
power: uber/balanced/weak etc.
special: fire/ice/sword etc.
weak in: close combat/speed etc.
strong in: ranged combat/defense etc.
mp usage: high/low/none etc.

[Hero destroyer]

Yea, that's good, too. Haven't thought of that.

[Jahvansi]

the classification of bamboori sounds very good to me -> thumbs up

[Silverthorn]

Well, the characters-section of the mainsite contains 186 characters at the moment. I simply don't have the time to go through all characters (and neither does MH), determine their properties, and update all pages.

If anybody is willing to categorize them all, speak up now or remain silent forever. And ever. And ever.

[Ariel]

Well, the characters-section of the mainsite contains 186 characters at the moment. I simply don't have the time to go through all characters (and neither does MH), determine their properties, and update all pages.

If anybody is willing to categorize them all, speak up now or remain silent forever. And ever. And ever.

u can do a group on the forum about 4~5 ppl that checking chars
let say 2 chars in day 5 days in week thats mean 40~ chars in week and they can check all the chars in less than 2 mounths
each char they do they can post it somthing like what bamboori said in some special forum for them and than you the admins just need to put the details for each char
if agree i can help with this and if there will be more ppl than 4~5 it will be faster

[Hero destroyer]

I have time, but have no idea how to edit a webpage. But do it just like Marshall once said:"brick by brick".

[YinYin]

Well, the characters-section of the mainsite contains 186 characters at the moment. I simply don't have the time to go through all characters (and neither does MH), determine their properties, and update all pages.

If anybody is willing to categorize them all, speak up now or remain silent forever. And ever. And ever.

you just need to add two features and everything will sort itself:
-sort/filter by rating
-and separate ratings for the suggested things on each char

thus anyone with the required time and interest in this kind of categorization can rate each character upon their strength and other aspects

[Silverthorn]

you just need to add two features and everything will sort itself:
-sort/filter by rating
-and separate ratings for the suggested things on each char

thus anyone with the required time and interest in this kind of categorization can rate each character upon their strength and other aspects

Good idea!

I figured out how to add additional ratings to the characters, so that works out nicely. However, one thing left to do: translate the properties into 5-star-ratings. Strength, for example, is fairly intuitive. Few stars: weak, many stars: strong. However, how to add the others? Ie. "Weak in" is not really the thing that can be added like that :/

tl;dr: which exact properties should be votable on each char?