RaMafia (round 1 - end)

[empirefantasy]

wow this game is turning really weird, probability this is the last day round coz during the night we will have 2 or 3 kills.

interesting fact that players who didnt vote were killed tonight. Well, it's good for SK, since he may think that those players who voted will kill each other in other rounds, while the other players who dont prefer to vote, he kills them personally. just an idea btw

@Ramond im sorry for you bro, told you that random killing is bad :/ it would have been better if we would have one more townie around

I have an idea who can be SK or mafia but i am waiting for your opinions guys...

---

duh you nave

yea, that what i was talking about jeremies

Ramond edited this post 05-03-2015 09:30 PM because:

Well I didn't tell you to vote ME now, have I

[TheNave]

Sigh switching to empirefantasy then

[Apocalipsis]

Why Jernemies? If you provide solid evidence I may follow.

Ariel was here two hours ago but didn't end this night... so I'm gonna write down the names of those that didn't visit the forum in the last 24 hours: empirefantasy, Hellblazer, TheNave.

I'm gonna asume that at least one of those three had special roles. Hellblazer was a townie. So it's either empirefantasy or TheNave.

If one of those two is the Vigilante and he's going to get killed by lynching, he can reveal himself to avoid it, and we'll still get the night shot.
If someone lies claiming to be the Vigilante, the real one can shot him at night.

For now, I'm voting TheNave.

Edit: Ninja'd, but post still applies.

[Ramond]

Nave seems to be checking who is just bandwagoning for no reason, which ef did. Makes him less suspicious.

[Dr. Time]

I think Apoc's theory might be solid.Either ef or Nave.
Although I really don't know how Jernemies can be one without solid evidence.

But the question is, why did Nave take J's name in the first place?
1. Nave took a random pick
2. Nave is the tracker, J has a special role of either SK or Vig. (Killed Hellblazer/Luti)
3. Aliens.

I'll go with [b]Nave[ /b] for now.

[Hellblazer]

Eh, that juice got me out.
Ariel, i luv that luti ava. <3

[TheNave]

Nave seems to be checking who is just bandwagoning for no reason, which ef did. Makes him less suspicious.

^this.

Oh and empirefantasy because:
He was in no way suspicious about me, even though I expected everyone to vote for me this day, he simply jumped on my convienently placed bandwagon

makes him feel really mafia/sk-ish... also if you check his previous posts he always seems to be talking alot about the SK in some way

---

Okay, I'm at home now and can go into detail a little bit more with my theory:

So, first up, the whole purpose of the strategy I came up last day, was to lure out non-citizens in a psychological way
If you think about it: Townies have no clue about who is who, so when somebody comes up with a strategy/theory/whatever, they will always criticize it, in case it's from mafia/sk and they obviously don't want to get fooled
but when a non-citizen sees such a theory, they know it's from a townie, and are more likely to agree with it since they want to go unnoticed especially when they're the minority...
and as you can see from the responses, luti and ef did not oppose my idea atall, while f.e. apoc and ramond heavily criticized it...
well now that some roles have been revealed, we can see, that luti was actually mafia, and ramond was innocent, which heavily favours my theory about mafia/sk agreeing and citizens opposing that said strategy
second thing is, I randomly selected a name for the second day which had no real impact in the game so far, and wanted to see the reactions of other members... I expected the reaction to be like this:
-Citizens: I was already suspicious in the first day round and think that most townies consider me mafia/sk already, so I thought that if I bring up a random name, they'd definatley not agree with me and accuse me even more
-Mafia/SK: They know I'm on the opposite team, so if I'd accuse any person, they'd have no problem to join the bandwagon and vote for that person aswell, as they don't have any disadvantages from doing so
and as you could see, ef Instantly joined that vote, he even stated that he already has (Quote "an idea who can be SK or mafia but [he is] waiting for your opinions"... which is complete bullsh*t when it comes to jeremies because I can't think of any valid idea how he'd be suspicious other than beeing slightly inactive... That sentence alone is, in my opinion, only a lame justification of killing somebody random as long as it's not him

So my conclusion would be: EF is not innocent... I dunno if he's SK or Mafia, but either way he's not on our side


PS: @Ramond I didn't want you to die, I actually didn't count the votes and did not expect two to be enough to kill somebody, I was confused by the constant vote changes and in my memory I assumed there were more people with 2 votes already, my bad, I'm sorry, I actually didn't think you were mafia

[Dr. Time]

Although the theory seems legit, I still beg to differ: What if Jernemies wasn't a random pick? That would mean that you are the Mafia tracker, Jernemies has a special role.

As stated by Apoc previously, the 3 who didn't come online were you, ef, and HB.
So actually, either you or ef is pretty much most likely of being a Mafia.

I'd like to see what the others think about this first before I change my vote.

Hey Nave, you do realize that if ef turns out to be a townie, you'll be in a pretty problematic situation, right?

If one of those two is the Vigilante and he's going to get killed by lynching, he can reveal himself to avoid it, and we'll still get the night shot.
If someone lies claiming to be the Vigilante, the real one can shot him at night.

Seconded.

[LutiChris]

Sorry Nave but just for fun and curiosity i'm going to see if the townies believe me. Nave is my partner in crime but if you kill him he won't be able to track down the serial killer. He's only your secondary problem since our roles were diminished.

[TheNave]

@Dr. Time
well I have chosen him at random, it's your decision whether to belive me or not
and yes, you're right, if ef turns out to be a townie I'm pretty much screwed, but can't do anything about that

@LutiChris
sigh, that's why ghosts shouldn't be allowed to talk .___. don't you think I'm in enough trouble already? :/