Classic Mafia - Conclusion!

[Simoneon]

Hahaha, I'll be laughing if it's actually Ramond & Nave. What a good show you made especially at the begining of the game

[mfc]

Apoc's death would show that bad math can kill you.

[Darl]

So why are you going for Bamboori now? Imo the only way of winning is to lynch the top three suspects of the list, as in Apocalypsis, Simoneon and LutiChris... lynching anyone else will always go in the favour of mafia

I don't fully agree with your suspicions. Putting that aside, I feel having Apoc around is way more useful than Bamboori, even if you think he's spreading bad info with just some maths that can actually be disregarded, since we're not playing around probabilities here. Bamboori is way too inactive and at this point in the game that's more harmful than good. Been thinking this since I posted my list.

[TheNave]

you kidding me right? please look back at how Bamboori voted for mfc without any sign of hesitation... if he was mafia he would atleast waited for some responses of other players before sealing the deal and killing of his own partner

and yes, having Apoc around is probably more usefull than bamboori, but having apoc around that is mafia is way worse

EDIT:
Actually, no. Having Apoc around this game isn't even good to beginn with... did he bring up anything usefull other than a hunch and wrong math that will end up killing citizens? did he in any way just once look at what the players are even talking and basing his accusation on that? No. He didn't, he's not helping Town at all this round... period.

[Jernemies]

Just throwing this out there, it doesn't seem to me like Apoc is even trying to find a suspicious "suspect". It looks an awful lot like he's just trying to wast our lynches away. I didn't really pay attention other than Apoc is trying his hands at propability math.

Why do I see propability math in this thread anyway? It could work if we were playing like ten thousand games at once and calculating the median, but shocker, we are not. Imagine us playing every round like this. It'd be like a lottery, where Gm just goes "Everybody ready? Roll the dice! Aaand the winner is... Mafia!" *two guys cheer*

Once again, I will listen to your concerns if you think domeone is suspicious. I won't listen to this math bullsh*t though.

Tl:dr didn't read, saw numbers, anger ensues.

[empirefantasy]

after some research i have decided that most likely to be mafia are luti bambori and simon. they all voted amadis. they have never voted for each other.
ramond looks like he is trying to reveal personalities by voting so much. while apoc generally provide good information. nave do them both. looking from the votes these players have usually voted for each other but not in the final decision. still in my eyes they are less likely to be mafia.

as for darl and jeremies i have talked before.

@nave
y you want to keep focusing on luti and not on bambori? what makes luti more suspicious than bambori?
OK youre right. im going for LUTI. but what about simon? he were in your list too

[Darl]

you kidding me right? please look back at how Bamboori voted for mfc without any sign of hesitation... if he was mafia he would atleast waited for some responses of other players before sealing the deal and killing of his own partner

and yes, having Apoc around is probably more usefull than bamboori, but having apoc around that is mafia is way worse

EDIT:
Actually, no. Having Apoc around this game isn't even good to beginn with... did he bring up anything usefull other than a hunch and wrong math that will end up killing citizens? did he in any way just once look at what the players are even talking and basing his accusation on that? No. He didn't, he's not helping Town at all this round... period.

He voted mfc after this comment

Obvious, You are mafia too and sacrificing your friend? Oh right, that is me. And you dont need to be afraid when actual cop checks you, since you are the godfather.

Literally after mfc himself admitted to being a Mafia. Heck, I'd say it'd make you FAR more suspicious to not vote against him or even defend him in any way whatosever.

---

Well, since Jernemies voted and Apoc's fate is sealed, I'll stop looking around the posts and making an argument. I'll just say this: if Apoc is mafia I'll admit I'm f***ing terrible at this.

[Jernemies]

after some research i have decided that most likely to be mafia are luti bambori and simon. they all voted amadis. they have never voted for each other.
ramond looks like he is trying to reveal personalities by voting so much. while apoc generally provide good information. nave do them both. looking from the votes these players have usually voted for each other but not in the final decision. still in my eyes they are less likely to be mafia.

See? This is exactly what I want to see, this is what I am talking about. Not something like " by a chance of 88.76% this guy is mafia", because that is 100% useless in yhis game of mindgames and personalities. For some reason I got irrationally angry about that.

[TheNave]

@Darl
Wait, are you talking about bamboori or apoc now? I cannot seem to find that post, can you link to it?
but anyways that quote sounds really sarcastic, I would consider it meaningless no matter who wrote it

@empirefantasy
please elaborate how Apoc is generally providing usefull information...
I'm on @Jernemies side here, he's just trying to waste our lynches

[Darl]

Obvious, You are mafia too and sacrificing your friend? Oh right, that is me. And you dont need to be afraid when actual cop checks you, since you are the godfather.

I dont like this strategy. I know we talked about it but I never said I agreed. GoodLuck winning the game with 1 mafia left. yes, i am sorry, i am a butthurt loser who is taking his team down sinilar to the last game. I am betrayed again...

Who cares, Aint gonna keep this game like this. You acted without getting my permission now mafia loses because of your actions. I dont thihnk I am unethical this game too for making mafia lose. He acted as an independent rather than as a team. His fault.

@TheNave Here you go. Talking about Bam, since you mentioned him voting mfc without hesitation.