(03-26-2010, 12:33 PM)LutiChris Wrote: when do our submissions get added?
or is it choosy mods...have we not found the right smilies or will this turn into a gallery?
You know, I was actually planning to replace the entire smiley-gallery. Means: somebody will have to start a replacement of

,
.gif)
, :o, :P, and the other ones. I haven't seen anything matching the quality I would like to have till now.
Let me point out some.... I'll just call them flaws (the creators will know who's is theirs):
•
![[Image: smile3o.png]](http://img19.imageshack.us/img19/3320/smile3o.png)
- the general shape is questionable. As to general opinion, a smiley should be a circle.
•
![[Image: exportwizard2.png]](http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/6964/exportwizard2.png)
- same problem. Jagged edge etc. In addition, without any annotation, I would not have recognized it as an orange.
•
![[Image: catsmiley1.gif]](http://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee74/THXPhil/catsmiley1.gif)
- "cat"-smileys are okay, yet I do not plan to replace the basic ones with these. I mean, one or two "special" cat-smilieys are fine, yet I doubt if it would be beneficial if they're just there for an alternative to

or whatever.
•
![[Image: bh3brnhny6bs7ulqk.gif]](http://666kb.com/i/bh3brnhny6bs7ulqk.gif)
- probably the most matching ones so far. I just wonder why everybody sticks to monochromatic designs. How about a bit of color?
For those of you that need a little reference for smileys, please have a look at >
this link<
Should help a little, especially with shading and shape.