RaMafia (round 1 - end)

[mfc]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH 1111111 11 11 11 LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL THIS IS HOW WE WIN. HAHAHAHAHA

FOLLOW MY LEAD MY BELIEVERS
I PROPHECIED. IT CAME TRUE.
BELIEVE ME.
SAY WOLOLO.

2 THUGS. 2. 2.

[MangaD]

Now that both thugs are out, I am putting my faith on the cop.

[mfc]

Truth. (Click to View)

1. A-Man - Citizen
2. Rhino - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
3. prince - Thug
4. STM - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
5. Hellblazer - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
6. MnM - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
7. Luti - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
8. MangaD -Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
9. mfc - Citizen or Doc or Sheriff
10. Amadis - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
11. Jernemies - Thug
12. Apocalipsis - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff
13. empirefantasy - Citizen or Mafia or Doc or Sheriff also Mayor

best part:

anyway, i don't think ill be dying anytime soon.

oh my sides
wololo, my friend, rest in pieces.

So, onto the day.
I sense that sheriff knows his stuff and gathering good infos. Maybe he even in contact with the doc.
So, I don't care however everyone acts or talks, I will go for no-kill vote because i don't want to risk anything anymore.

You will be like,
"Oh no he sent me fake pm"
"Oh no he so silent"
"Oh no he talks too much to get attention"
"Oh no he suspiciously votes for things"
etc etc. But no, none is provable and for the best of the herd, no one must be lynched.
And imagine, you chose actual doc or sheriff with your unreliable methods and got close to killing him. He would have to confess his profession and things would get only worse for the herd.

Even if we get a mafia by chance, they still have 2 more, they will keep killing. But not wort the risk at this point.

But I have to admit, mafias, you are brilliant.

[MangaD]

Vote no-kill.

[mfc]

Then you want the majority of us to vote no-kill every day phase until the Sheriff finds all the Mafias? If you try to come up with "That's what I'm gonna do, I'm not suggesting the majority to do the same", I will have to ask "Why you vote for that option if you don't want it to happen?". I see only a posible reason for that: because you would want to avoid responsibilities. I don't think I have to explain why I would find that suspicious.
Please explain what is so suspicious about repeating what luti said and turned out to be correct?
We cannot afford to force doc or sheriff to expose themselves by threatening them to death.

But if you really want no-kill each day round, I have found two problems with that strategy:
1. It would make the game extremely boring for citizens. If we always go for no-kill, then why keep posting here? It would be a Sheriff/Doctor/Mafias-only game, with little input from non-specials.
Sheriff and doc will eventually come to contact with citizens very likely. And that is where citizens must start deciding smartly. Yes, we wont be doing anything special yet, so I would say let's act fast and day finally become over, boring times pass faster.
2. What happens if he dies before that? Remember that there's a rule that forbids him of posting information he got outside of the public
At this point he had 2 days, he probably already found at least one citizen unless he went for pf and jernemies lol but very unlikely(?)haaha. So, dont worry I would say about the information loss. He will have someone to relay that info very likely.

[STM1993]

Welp, I've got nothing to hide anymore now that both thugs are dead. I was hoping to make Mafia think I'm a thug so I don't get killed in the night. Vote no-lynch.

Come at me, Mafia!

[LutiChris]

no-lynch

[Rhino.Freak]

Lol that was unexpected XD
That's what you get thugs! These mafia have no friends!
I agree with no-lynch part, if doctor dies, it's game over.

So I vote No Lynch

[Apocalipsis]

If I'm not mistaken, there were only 2.5% chances of that happening xD

Please explain what is so suspicious about repeating what luti said and turned out to be correct?
We cannot afford to force doc or sheriff to expose themselves by threatening them to death.

I don't know what "what luti said" refers to.
You didn't have a problem about that in the past day (there were less chances, but still).
My point there was that votings against another player, turn out to be evidence later in the game, when Mafia roles are discovered. So it's safer for them to go with no-kill.

Sheriff and doc will eventually come to contact with citizens very likely. And that is where citizens must start deciding smartly. Yes, we wont be doing anything special yet, so I would say let's act fast and day finally become over, boring times pass faster.

We won't have to decide smartly. Someone will tell us "X is mafia", and we will have to vote against X.

At this point he had 2 days, he probably already found at least one citizen unless he went for pf and jernemies lol but very unlikely(?)haaha. So, dont worry I would say about the information loss. He will have someone to relay that info very likely.

We get to know this just now. I stated that reason before Ramond's post. Before, he could have checked a Thug and get a "innocent" result, so sharing information would be dangerous. Since he can share information about his checkings while alive, I'm pretty sure he can PM them to someone innocent.


I guess I'll go with no lynch then.

[MangaD]

If I'm not mistaken, there were only 2.5% chances of that happening xD

12.5%

My point there was that votings against another player, turn out to be evidence later in the game, when Mafia roles are discovered. So it's safer for them to go with no-kill.

I'm afraid they don't. Everyone can make mistakes, everyone can suspect the wrong person. It is even possible - though unlikely - that no one from the Mafia voted on A-Man.

We won't have to decide smartly. Someone will tell us "X is mafia", and we will have to vote against X.

Assuming there are no deviant citizens, then yeah.

But more than knowing who is Mafia, it would also help to know who is not.

Before, he could have checked a Thug and get a "innocent" result, so sharing information would be dangerous. Since he can share information about his checkings while alive, I'm pretty sure he can PM them to someone innocent.

That is pretty much it.