RaMafia 2

[A-Man]

No kill - 2 (Rhino.Freak and Tornado)

Somebody get these 2 the Nobel prize of peace

I demand you change your votes away from this dummy option!

[T.O.R.N.A.D.O]

Well the lynch is pretty much one sided. It doesn't matter if I change my vote to you or anyone else. But to honor your last wish I choose a random lynch. And empirefantasy is the winner.

[MangaD]

On the other hand, killing an inquisitor is a 50/50 chance of killing a werewolf.

There is one more option: WW has no Inq. Then killing Inq(s) might mean you are lynching 100% townies.

Yes but I was depicting the case of a 1vs1 inquisitor battle. As I said, the most reasonable scenario would be a 2vs1 inquisitor battle (although with ghost talk enabled who knows). There is also the possibility of having 1vs0 inquisitor battle I guess? But in any case, I think killing the inquisitors is a bad idea, unless we have the 1vs1 scenario, which we don't know.

[A-Man]

Well the lynch is pretty much one sided. It doesn't matter if I change my vote to you or anyone else. But to honor your last wish I choose a random lynch. And empirefantasy is the winner.

To choose to cast a random vote after 'honoring' my wish and removing the no-kill option from your list of options  can only mean one of 2 things:
1- You voluntarily do not wish to express your opinion on a matter that's relevant to you, which is generally considered bad.
2- You see the current situation (aka me being the one death row) to most coincide with your view, but you don't want to show it for some reason ; in which case you should change it and vote to lynch me.

Let me know if there is a 3rd option. You can't say that you believe none is worse than the other because after reading a 100 posts in this thread, you must have got a little list with the slightest hunch of who may be a werewolf.

Yes but I was depicting the case of a 1vs1 inquisitor battle. As I said, the most reasonable scenario would be a 2vs1 inquisitor battle (although with ghost talk enabled who knows). There is also the possibility of having 1vs0 inquisitor battle I guess? But in any case, I think killing the inquisitors is a bad idea, unless we have the 1vs1 scenario, which we don't know.

Agree. That's why I was suggesting we try to find the second inquisitor first before taking any action. The fact that he remains hiding does make him more suspicious to me though.

Lynch Neeragon LutiChris!

[Rhino.Freak]

I guess I'll change my vote to A-man then.

That makes:

Just making this lynch scoreboard.

• A-man - 6 (TheNave, Simoneon, Bamboori, Neeragon, Rhino.Freak and LutiChris)
  
• empirefantasy - 1 (tornado)
  
• LutiChris - 1 (A-man)
  
• Bamboori - 1 (MangaD)
  

[T.O.R.N.A.D.O]

The main point here is that your idea is reckless. Because of this reckless idea people are trying to lynch you. And this is not only limited to this game but in all the previous rounds, you create a commotion which makes the masses lynch you. But generally you are a citizen. It's my hunch that you are still a citizen who is trying to create a commotion in the midst. So I am not supporting you in this charade and don't want to lynch you because of my hunch. My hunch may very well be wrong since you are trying to kill all the inquisitors and Knights which will make the werewolves win like a breeze but it really doesn't matter since you already are in a death row. Changing my vote to you or any other won't do any good. So it's pretty much random. But if you desperately want me to lynch you then I don't have any problem in it. Just know that much.

[A-Man]

I guess I'll change my vote to A-man then.

Great. Now all that remains is the reasoning behind your vote.

As for why I voted LutiChris. He, Neeragon and Bamboori were ones to refuse to come up with any sort of argument against my logic, and simply voted against me. I chose to exclude Bamboori because if what he says is true (supported by TheNave's confirmation when he admitted being an Inquisitor), then he becomes a key player in this game. But that still doesn't render him safe yet, so we'll need to hear one (or more) other check results of his. I was firstly going with Neeragon, but I figured his actions may just be that of a new player. So LutiChris it was.

---

The main point here is that your idea is reckless. Because of this reckless idea people are trying to lynch you. And this is not only limited to this game but in all the previous rounds, you create a commotion which makes the masses lynch you. But generally you are a citizen. It's my hunch that you are still a citizen who is trying to create a commotion in the midst. So I am not supporting you in this charade and don't want to lynch you because of my hunch. My hunch may very well be wrong since you are trying to kill all the inquisitors and Knights which will make the werewolves win like a breeze but it really doesn't matter since you already are in a death row. Changing my vote to you or any other won't do any good. So it's pretty much random. But if you desperately want me to lynch you then I don't have any problem in it. Just know that much.

To vote no-kill, and randomly in this case, is no less reckless (if not more). I simply proposed an effective idea that's out of what you get used to in an more ordinary mafia game variation. Some chose to lock their heads to it. Others acted out of defense from what they thought may harm them. The minority challenged it and disagreed with it and faithfully believe their own strategy would do better. Either way, if what you saw was such a mass that have gathered on voting to lynch me and collectively in any way disagreed with my plan, then this may hint to whether I have a group who know facts about my identity and support me or not.

However, if you really see me at the top of the list then don't hesitate to vote against me. The last I'd want to see is members of the town following whatever trend werewolf agents may come up with instead of going with the healthy deductions they've made on their own.

[T.O.R.N.A.D.O]

No random vote in this case is nowhere near reckless as the plan you are suggesting. Here it is more like you are gonna die anyway so no point in voting another vote against you. As I already said that I have a hunch that you are citizen which makes me not to vote for you. But if you insist then lynch A-man .

I think it's high time to end this day since the vote is pretty much one sided.

[A-Man]

you are gonna die anyway so no point in voting another vote against you

That happens to be the weakest argument I've heard today as it's totally yelling argumentum ad populum in my face. Your argument is invalid, and thus your vote is unfair as it doesn't reflect your own conclusion. I'm only insisting you vote on your #1 suspect. But if you choose to be stubborn and blindly follow it, then that makes a spot on your record this entire game.

[T.O.R.N.A.D.O]

See, I like to play my game based on my own opinions. This round has not even gone far enough to pin point the suspects. I am doing my own research and when I think that I have enough evidence to withstand my claim, I will openly reveal it. For now I have no concrete proof against any of my suspects that's why I went for no-kill in the first place. I changed my vote for the sole reason of you asking us to change it. I have changed my votes long enough. I am going to stick with you now. Idk this much stubbornness based on my vote really makes me doubt my hunch. So congrats you have become one of my suspects.