Classic Mafia - Conclusion!

[Apocalipsis]

Town/Mafia Ratio is 9:3

Shouldn't it be 10:2?

STM1993 edited this post 02-28-2016 03:11 AM because:

My bad, fixed. Yes, its 10 : 2

[LutiChris]

@stm you're not making this any easier for me but i'll find a way to bend these rules!

[AmadisLFE]

Nice job on destroying MFC there Nave! ( Pssst, talking about the screenshot, not the actual lynch, don't mind me Rhino )

I would say Rhino is a little clear, but lets see eh?

[Darl]

@stm you're not making this any easier for me but i'll find a way to bend these rules!

Why are you griefing?

[LutiChris]

@Darl
Yes, I really wanted to post some fake screenshots like the last time. Those were the good old days
Now nobody believes me anymore because im a pathological liar

[Rhino.Freak]

Oh my lovely doctor, protect me this night so I can continue checking and wrecking people.

I already know whom to check

[Simoneon]

@Luti: It's not that you're a pathological liar or that you troll in every game you're in that makes me smile. It's that you invest so much time into your bullsh*t that it actually becomes pitiful :D
I posted the screenshot not to cheat on you specifically, I would have posted every post that was deleted with valuable information and definitely not because of you, but because as I said, I don't think it's fair if me and Ramond see them (which is not in our hands to change, it's how the forum works) and the rest of the players don't. I wouldn't do this kind of thing regularly and lastly... how the hell you think I could be posting as you? Ask STM to check IPs of your posts or anything. Knowing your past, however, we all know what a troll you are (you even managed to randomly create a new account recently :D). I'm sorry if you didn't know we can read deleted post and it was unexpected to you. But don't go around flaming me for your own mistakes.

If anyone would actually believe what Luti said about me, please ask STM to clarify if the screenshots are genuine and whether it's reasonable just for two players to see hidden posts.

PS: I wouldn't vote for LutiChris just because of this behaviour, as I said it's typical and doesn't make him mafia. I would check on him though.
However, now there's a possibility that mafia will target me in the night and it would look like LutiChris wanted to kill me. Don't be blinded by that in case I die tonight. It would actually be a pretty good plan by mafia to kill two citizens... So I'd check him first and then decide.

[TheNave]

In case I don't survive this night, thoughts so far:

1. mfc (100%) - dead mafia scum
   
2. Ramond (85%) - Highly suspicious! He went along with mfcs 'Rhino is mafia, too'-lie without even hesitating while criticizing all town-sided scenarios people came up with, also made up that fake Cop ability to prevent the doc from saving rhino tonight, all his actions made no sense from a citizen point of view...
   
3. LutiChris (50%) - Sigh, dunno about that one, I think his posts are just pure troll and should be ignored, we could decide to lynch him when we have no better clues because trolling is never helping and just working against the town... for a second I thought his posts might have influenced Ramond, but now that their correct position has been restored I could confirm that that's not the case at all
   
4. CosmicSarasa (50%) - Just a couple of one-liner posts, he did jump on the bandwagon to lynch mfc after there was no helping him anyways, most posts just repeated somebody elses thoughts, no information from him to gain here
   
5. Apocalipsis (35%) - Actively playing the game, consideres multiple scenarios from every point of view like Apoc typically does it, also taunted mfc... he's an experienced player so it might be an act but for now he didn't look suspicious to me yet
   
6. Bamboori (30%) - Didn't write much at all, yet he was one of the first once to vote for mfc and he didn't even hesitated a bit after Rhino accused him, looks fine to me
   
7. Jernemies (30%) - No posts yet, might be lurking mafia, but he didn't even vote in day 1 so he's probably just inactive
   
8. Darl (25%) - Went against mfc, came up with own thoughts, considered different scenarios, declared Ramonds fake Cop hidden ability post as bullsh*t, looks like a solid citizen to me
   
9. Simoneon (25%) - Taunted mfc, didn't hesitate to lynch him, came up with own thoughts and scenarios, classic citizen behaviour
   
10. empirefantasy (25%) - Didn't pay that much attention to the game at the beginning, aparently was to lazy to read most of the posts and needed a summary... I doubt mafia members that have private conversations would end up in such a situation
    
11. AmadisLFE (15%) - Missed Night 0, wasn't online until Day 1, unlikely for him to have a role that requires nightactivity
    
12. Rhino.Freak (5%) - Confirmed Cop in my opinion until somebody else claims to be, should be saved at night!
    
13. TheNave (0%) - Citizen
    
14. T.O.R.N.A.D.O (0%) - died a hero!
    

[STM1993]

If anyone would actually believe what Luti said about me, please ask STM to clarify if the screenshots are genuine and whether it's reasonable just for two players to see hidden posts.

Just to make it clear if people missed the "Restored Luti's posts" in the night 1 begins post and my thanks to Simon's posts, yes, those screenshots are genuine.

And no, I don't believe it is fair for players to delete their posts, with or without moderators playing the game because it means only some people can see the post if they caught the original post prior to deletion or are mods who just can see deleted stuff. I've also expanded that into editted posts.

[Ramond]

Ramond (85%) - Highly suspicious! He went along with mfcs 'Rhino is mafia, too'-lie without even hesitating while criticizing all town-sided scenarios people came up with, also made up that fake Cop ability to prevent the doc from saving rhino tonight, all his actions made no sense from a citizen point of view...

You know we're playing a game without private discussions right? As a Citizen, what else can you do but to bluff and lure the Mafia out of its comfort zone?

I never criticized any town-sided scenario except for Rhino being the Cop. I said the Doc shouldn't save me tonight. Get your facts straight.

I did not accuse Rhino because mfc said so. I did so because you were so sure of it as your first vote during the day. I used that fact to pressure him and sound like I had dirt on him. And since we're playing without any private communication, your behaviour really does not work in favor of you being a typical Citizen, because you would know what I was up to and support my bluffs.

Therefore, Nave is next. Kill Nave tomorrow.