Classic Mafia - Conclusion!

[Bamboori]

Literally after mfc himself admitted to being a Mafia. Heck, I'd say it'd make you FAR more suspicious to not vote against him or even defend him in any way whatosever.

So did Simon (even before me). Why wouldn't it make sense for a citizen to vote for an obvious mafia member?

Putting that aside...

Right after Empirefantasy, who only recently presented his first feasible theory, (at that point) randomly votes for me, Apoc starts to come up with a math equation that makes me 76.92% mafia.


If Apoc turns out to be mafia, our next target should be Empirefantasy.

[TheNave]

@Darl
ahh okay, now explain how it would be more mafia-ish to instantly vote for mfc than to not vote for him...

@Bamboori
just like Amadis, empirefantasy did miss out some Night-Phases so it's very unlikely for him to be anything other than a citizen

[Bamboori]

It still is possible though. We can discuss this when Apoc is lynched, then we'll have more clues anyway.

[Darl]

@Darl
ahh okay, now explain how it would be more mafia-ish to instantly vote for mfc than to not vote for him...

...isn't that what I said? If Bambori had not voted for Mfc at that point, that would had made him far more suspicious.

[TheNave]

Yes yes, I was defending Bamboori... I think we kinda missunderstood eachother

[Rhino.Freak]

BoooOooOooOoooOOoooooOOOOO

[STM1993]

Here's the vote count at the moment:
1. AmadisLFE
2. Apocalipsis - #5/11/13: Bamboori
3. Bamboori - #14: Apocalipsis
4. CosmicSarasa
5. Darl - #15: Bamboori
6. empirefantasy - #10/16: LutiChris
7. Jernemies - #16: Apocalipsis
8. LutiChris - #8: LutiChris
9. mfc
10. Ramond - #1/7/9: Apocalipsis
11. Rhino.Freak
12. Simoneon - #3: TheNave
13. TheNave - #2/4/6/12: Apocalipsis
14. T.O.R.N.A.D.O

Vote Tally:
Apoc - 4
Bamboori - 2
LutiChris - 2
TheNave - 1

I'm not advancing the phase just yet since I've been told I moved the day phase too quickly last time during a close contest, but I shall proceed either roughly 20 hours from now or when one person is a very clear choice like what happened with mfc.

Also quick announcement in advance: I won't be able to update the game at my usual time on Saturday due to class in the morning.

[empirefantasy]

@nave here

Spoiler (Click to View)

Since no other player claimed to be the Cop, I guess I will have to believe that Rhino is the real one.

First of all, I will ask every player that claims to be Town-aligned, to make a list of thoughts about each player, like Nave did. Silent players only help the Mafia.

Confirmed facts (Click to View)

1. AmadisLFE
2. Apocalipsis
3. Bamboori
4. CosmicSarasa - Citizen
5. Darl
6. empirefantasy
7. Jernemies
8. LutiChris
9. mfc - Mafia Goon
10. Ramond
11. Rhino.Freak
12. Simoneon
13. TheNave
14. T.O.R.N.A.D.O - Citizen

I will add to my list:
* I know I'm citizen.
* I'll assume from now on that Rhino is the real Cop, thus Darl is safe until we find the other Goon.

My list (Click to View)

1. AmadisLFE
2. Apocalipsis
3. Bamboori
4. CosmicSarasa - Citizen
5. Darl - Citizen?
6. empirefantasy
7. Jernemies
8. LutiChris
9. mfc - Mafia Goon
10. Ramond
11. Rhino.Freak - Cop?
12. Simoneon
13. TheNave
14. T.O.R.N.A.D.O - Citizen

Current opinion about each player:

• Amadis: Active. He goes with the flow in this game, just like in the last game (this might be his way of playing). TORNADO said he wanted to lynch him next phase, and he died at night (he may have been joking, but these are facts).
  
• Bamboori: Active.
  
• Empirefantasy: Not so active.
  
• Jernemies: Inactive. My guess is that he's bored because of his role, or busy. Then again, he acted like this in the last game, and he was Mafia.
  
• LutiChris: Inactive (then started trolling). He's always like this.
  
• Ramond: Active. I thought he hinted to be the real Cop and gave false abilities to avoid being the target at night, or that he was hinting that there's a Trapper in the game... but I guess I was wrong, and he just wanted to put pressure on Rhino or something.
  
• Simoneon: Active. His doubts about Rhino make me think that he's probably citizen... but it's just a hunch.
  
• TheNave: Active. I don't fully trust him yet, but he always spills a lot of information, which is good for citizens.
  

Unfortunately, I still don't have enough information to make a 'secure' vote. Also, there are some players which I find suspicious, because there was nothing I could put on the list about them (they blend very well): Bamboori and Empirefantasy.
Against all predictions, I'm voting Amadis again. It may be that his way of talking always makes me suspicious of him, but I felt the same in the last game, and he was Mafia.

so not to just waste my vote and go for no kill,no vote or vote any other random players i am risking luti
BUT i have to say to thenave that in case luti is citizen then you are in the top of suspect list!

Mmm... that "If X ends up being citizen, I'll vote Y next!" is suspicious here, since there's no reason to think that if Luti is citizen, Nave is mafia, or the other way around. Both may be citizen, or mafia. Mafias usually say that to kill two citizens in a row.

---

I want to remark that before I voted Amadis, there were 4 votes against Luti. Two of those votes were changed from Nave/Ramond to Luti.

but yes, its not that much. i just rechecked 2-3 last pages (50 posts/page) and most of his posts were short and not full with important info and thoughts. but still he is not on the top of my list since doesnt look that mafia in my eyes.


but as apoc is about to be judged today, i just hope he turns to be a mafia.

STM1993 edited this post 03-02-2016 03:19 PM because:

You're still free to discuss and change your votes during this 20 hour period I mentioned btw.

[Ramond]

Bamboori has been pretty passive in the game until his name appeared more often in Mafia suspect lists. Then his activity skyrocketed! (Well, kinda...)

Confirmed Mafia scum. And LutiChris is next, because after he saw how people stopped voting Nave due to his voting for himself, Luti as the Mafia resorted to this immediately to try to get the bandwagon off of him.

No more lies.

[Bamboori]

well if you're voted to be lynched wouldn't you naturally try to stay alive?
what's wrong with me being more active?